Addressing "Settler Violence": The Truth About The Jewish Inheritors of Samaria

The movement of Jewish families returning to Judea and Samaria is growing fast. Young couples are planting vineyards, starting businesses, building schools, and raising children in the biblical heartland, fulfilling the commandment to settle the land. Much like the rebuilding of Tel Aviv and Haifa a century ago, their return has brought prosperity to the region.
Until October 7th, 2023, many Arab workers were employed in construction across Judea and Samaria, and the growth benefited Arabs and Jews alike. Yet there is no other place on earth that receives as much international condemnation as Israel does for this resettlement, even while serious atrocities go almost unnoticed elsewhere in the world.
This is not a new story. When Nehemiah returned from Persia to rebuild the walls of Jerusalem, Sanballat and Tobiah mocked him in front of the army of Samaria. "What are these feeble Jews doing?" Sanballat sneered, and Tobiah joked that if even a fox climbed onto their wall, it would fall down (Nehemiah 4:2–3).
When mockery failed, they spread rumors, accused Nehemiah of rebellion against the king, and plotted violence. The builders worked with a tool in one hand and a weapon in the other (Nehemiah 4:17). Nehemiah's answer to his accusers was simple: "The God of heaven himself will prosper us; therefore we his servants will arise and build" (Nehemiah 2:20).
I believe the opposition today is just as spiritual. The powers of darkness tremble when three-thousand-year-old prophecies begin to be fulfilled. Through the Crusades, the Inquisition, the pogroms, and the Holocaust, the enemy sought to snuff out God's chosen light-bearers. Now God's word is being fulfilled before the eyes of the world, and his name is being hallowed through it.
That is why the bitterest hatred of Israel so often comes from those who are hostile to the God of Israel and his word. It shows up as violence, demonization, and blood libels, with Israel's leaders portrayed as criminals and the IDF as an instrument of genocide. Sadly, many pro-Israel believers fall for it when it comes to the settlers. They would never trust Al Jazeera on anything else about Israel, but when the headline is settler violence, they copy and paste it onto their social media.
I have lived among the settlers of Samaria for more than twenty years. Their hearts are golden. They are honest, hard-working, praying, Bible-believing people who love the God of Israel and love their neighbors. They are building the land as their heavenly King instructed them to.
Now, you could say, "Wait! What about the UN reports of settler violence?" An analysis by the Regavim Movement found that the incidents in a widely cited UN dataset consisted of traffic accidents, Jews visiting the Temple Mount, road paving in Area C, and even terrorists neutralized by soldiers in the act of an attack. These were all tallied under the heading of settler violence.
Yes, there have been rare crimes committed by the Jewish residents, and Israel's own courts prosecute them, as they should. But the numbers tell the real story. Over the last ten years, roughly 185 Israelis have been murdered in terror attacks in Judea and Samaria, a region with a Jewish population of about half a million.
The violence in Judea and Samaria flows overwhelmingly from the Arab population toward the Jewish population. I have personally been the target of multiple rock attacks. Two of my neighbors were shot point-blank while driving peacefully down the road, and two more were gunned down at a bus stop.
The truth is this hatred begins in the classroom. A study commissioned by the European Union itself, which examined 156 Palestinian Authority textbooks, found antisemitic tropes and terrorists who murdered Israelis held up as heroes. Watchdog groups like IMPACT-se have documented Palestinian children learning physics from a picture of a boy aiming a slingshot at Israeli soldiers.
The lesson does not stop at the school door. In Huwara, the Arab town at the foot of Har Bracha, I have seen with my own eyes the posters and memorials honoring terrorists as martyrs. When children are taught from their earliest years that Jews are the enemy and that their killers are heroes, we should not be surprised at what some of them grow up to do.
Jewish children in Samaria are raised on a very different text. They learn from the first chapter of the Torah that every human being is created in the image of God (Genesis 1:27). Young Jewish children begin their study of the Bible with the book of Leviticus, and I have stood in classrooms here in Samaria listening to them chant and memorize the very book that commands, "You shall love your neighbor as yourself" (Leviticus 19:18), and they learn from the sages that whoever destroys a single life is considered as though he destroyed an entire world (Mishnah Sanhedrin 4:5).
They are taught to act responsibly and go to whatever lengths necessary to avoid loss of life. Judaism has never taught that it is the only acceptable faith and that all others must be eradicated, as jihadist Islam does. On the contrary, the sages taught that the righteous among the nations have a share in the world to come. Not every Arab child absorbs the hatred he is taught, and the born-again Arab believers I have met with secretly in the olive groves of Samaria are living proof of that. But a society that celebrates its murderers and a society that mourns every lost life will produce very different neighbors.
What, then, about the Arab population living in Judea and Samaria? This question deserves far more space than one article can give it, but it cannot be ignored. Creating a twenty-third Arab state in the heart of Israel would mean the terrorizing and expulsion of the Jewish population, as the history of Jewish communities across the Arab world has shown, and it would be national suicide for Israel.
On the other hand, granting full citizenship to every Arab in Judea and Samaria would make Israel an Arab-majority state, which again would mean the end of the Jewish homeland. Without question, the best path is for Israel to apply sovereignty to the area and offer the Arab population citizenship with full civil protections but without national voting rights, much like Puerto Rico, whose residents are full U.S. citizens but cannot vote for president or elect voting members of Congress. Many would choose to stay, because life in Israel offers more security and opportunity than anywhere else in the region.
The truth that God gave this land to the Jewish people must be walked out alongside the truth that every human being is made in his image and deserves dignity and justice. The Torah provides a framework for this in the status of the ger toshav, the resident foreigner, who was to receive justice, protection, and care, and whom Israel was commanded to love as themselves (Leviticus 19:34).
Ruth the Moabite is a great example of a foreigner who blessed Israel and was blessed in return, so much so that she became the great-grandmother of King David. The reality on the ground is that the revival of the land has greatly benefited those among the Arab population who have embraced it. Those who bless Israel will be blessed. This is God's way.
While the nations mock, accuse, and condemn the heroic settlers on the mountains of Samaria, let's be the ones who stand on the wall beside them, who refuse to repeat the slanders of those who hate the God of Israel, and who bless these pioneers in their holy work, knowing that the God of heaven himself will prosper them and that their labor will bring blessing to everyone living in the land and to the whole world.





Comments